She had a point – how in the hell would the thief know what valuables to take if he were an outsider?
"Maybe he didn't have to ask," Ev offered. "Maybe the valuables were something that they wore on their person, or something they kept in plain sight in their houses. If only we knew what valuables were stolen..." Perhaps that was something they could ask a local guard later. He liked the theory that it was a villager amongst them that was stealing from them – it would explain why they knew just what valuables to take.
Someone who lived here for a while would know what treasures the villagers possessed, but that only begged the question – why start stealing from them now? "If it's a villager stealing from his peers, he'd need to have some kind of motive, something that happened to him recently that gave him reason to steal. Maybe he's run into hard times financially, or something along those lines. I doubt anyone who's been a long time villager would steal from his peers without good cause... but then again, you never know..." There's no such thing as halfway crooks – either they had a motive or they didn't.
And then, that was true – where would they stash the loot? "Good point. At this rate, I can't see any of the villagers stashing their loot in their homes, unless they blanketed it with some sort of concealing magic. Or maybe they can create magic pocket dimensions, in which to store the loot, perhaps." He had seen some knights, who weren't sure of which sword they should fight with, carry all of them in small pocket dimensions, so that they could call out a different weapon without having to carry it on their person. Perhaps the same situation was being dealt with here.
Calyse mentioned that they should go talk to the man at the bar, to which Ev bit his lip. The portly man seemed drunk out of his mind, and all the drunks Ev had ever encountered were pugnacious at best, but she was right – he seemed to be willing to talk about the case, if anything. "Let's go," he offered, standing up from the table. They had not yet been given their cider, but Ev hadn't cared about it in the first place.
"Excuse me, sir," Evangelus began – tilting his head toward the portly drunkard. "You seem to have had your belongings stolen as well. Do you mind telling me about what happened?"
The portly didn't turn around to face Ev at first, but merely slammed his mug down on the counter, groaning. "Tell you about what happened? You gotta be a damn fool if you don't know about –" He spun around at that moment, and from Ev's noble attire, realized immediately who he was talking to. At that moment, Ev didn't regret coming here in his best. "The Feyals," he spluttered out, immediately changing his tune. He grabbed his mug once again, took a swig of his beer, and held it up in the air. "The Feyals are here to catch that filanderin' bastard, everyone! Give 'em a cheer!" Most of the villagers in the pub let out a hearty cheer and a good round of claps, before returning to their alcohol.
"I'll tell you what happened. He strikes when you're not home, he does. Or she – maybe it's a damned flighty woman doin' all this, hell if I know. Anyway, he knows when you won't be home for some time. He knows when your neighbors aren't home too, and then he strikes. Hell if I know when he does it, but he can see – everything. He came into my home when I left for a three day trip into the mountains to get some minin' done with my crew. When we came back to the village, my silver spoons were gone!" He hissed, a drunken garble, but lowered his voice, so his drinking buddies wouldn't hear. "But that's not the scary part. There's a part that the guards forget to mention, there's a part that no one bothers to tell the guards when they come. He left me a note. From what I can gather, he left everyone a note. Here, come here, I'll show you."
He lead the Feyals off to the side, and pulled out a small piece of paper from his pocket. The paper seemed to be enchanted – despite how many times it had been folded, it didn't appear to be wrinkled. The words on it were written in a bold print, but it didn't seem to be ink. If anything, perhaps the ink had been enchanted, so that it would never smudge or smear. On the note, it read, in bold print, "TELL LARA WHAT YOU DID."
"Lara's my wife's name," the man replied, and he seemed to be a little sober when he said it. He hesitated, wondering if he should continue. "A year ago... I cheated on her. It was a one time thing, but, but still, I shouldn't have done it...." He growled, angry with himself, and the situation. "I told you – this guy knows everything. I think the others got notes too – but they won't talk about it. And I don't blame them, to be frank. If the notes are like mine – well, I don't talk about what my note says either."
"So, would you say..." Ev began, but the man cut him off.
"Yeah. All of us victims – I think we all got something to hide."